Serving St. Louis & Surrounding Areas

What Size Water Heater Do You Need in Oakville, St. Louis?
Figuring out what size water heater you need comes down to how much hot water your family uses in its busiest hour, not how big the house is. For most Oakville families, that means a 40 gallon tank for two or three people and a 50 gallon tank for four or five. Big families, big soaking tubs and electric tanks often need more than that.
Sam Marsala has been putting in water heaters around Oakville and the rest of St. Louis since 1998, and Liberty is still a family-owned company. We hear this question almost every time someone needs a new tank, usually right after they ran out of hot water halfway through a shower. Below is how we figure out the right size for a house, in plain words. If you already know you need a new one, our page on water heater installation in Oakville walks through how the swap works.
Start With Your Busiest Hour
The size of the tank isn’t about the whole day. It’s about the one hour when everybody wants hot water at once. In most houses that’s the morning, when people are getting ready for work and school. In others it’s right after dinner.
Think about what happens in that hour at your place. Here are rough numbers a lot of sizing guides use for hot water only:
- A shower: around 10 gallons of hot water
- Running the dishwasher: about 6 gallons
- A load of laundry on warm: about 7 gallons
- Washing hands and face, or shaving: a few gallons each
So say three people shower between 6:30 and 7:30, and someone starts the dishwasher before they leave. That’s about 36 gallons of hot water in one hour. Add a teenager who stays in the shower for 20 minutes and you can blow right past that.
Those numbers are only a starting point. An older showerhead can use a lot more water than a newer one, and some people like their showers much hotter than others.

The First Hour Rating on the Yellow Label
Every new tank comes with a bright yellow sticker on it. It’s called the EnergyGuide label, and most people never read it. Up in the top left corner there’s a line that says “Capacity (first hour rating).”
That number tells you how many gallons of hot water the tank can give you in one hour, starting full. It counts the hot water already in the tank plus what it can heat up during that hour. It’s more useful than the gallon size printed on the side.
Here’s why. Two tanks that both say 40 gallons can have pretty different first hour ratings. One might heat faster than the other. So when we size a tank, we match that rating to your busiest hour. If your family uses about 60 gallons of hot water between 6:30 and 7:30, you want a tank rated at 60 or a little higher.
If you like doing the math yourself, a U.S. Department of Energy lab has a free first hour rating calculator that adds up your busiest hour for you.
What a 30, 40 or 50 Gallon Tank Gives You in Showers
This is the part people care about. How many showers before somebody gets the cold one?
First, you don’t get every gallon in the tank at full heat. As hot water leaves the top, cold water comes in at the bottom to refill it. After a while that cold water starts mixing in and the shower cools off. On the other hand, you’re mixing cold water into your shower anyway, so the hot water goes further than you’d think.
With an average showerhead and normal length showers, here’s about what we see. Take these as rough numbers, not promises.
- 30 gallon tank: one long shower, or two short ones back to back. Good for one person or a couple who don’t shower at the same time.
- 40 gallon tank: about two showers back to back. A third one usually starts going lukewarm toward the end.
- 50 gallon tank: usually three showers in a row if nobody takes too long, and a little room for the dishwasher.
How long can one person stay in the shower on a 40 gallon tank? Alone, with nobody else using hot water, a lot of people get somewhere around 20 to 30 minutes before it starts cooling off. A low flow showerhead stretches that. An old one that blasts water shortens it.
40 or 50 Gallons: Which One Fits Your House?
Most homes around here end up choosing between these two sizes. Here’s how we usually decide.
When 40 Gallons Is Plenty
- One or two people live there, maybe three.
- Only one shower gets used in the morning, or people shower at different times.
- It’s a gas tank, so it heats back up faster.
When You Should Go to 50 Gallons
- Four or five people in the house.
- Two showers running at the same time most mornings.
- Teenagers. Enough said.
- It’s an electric tank, which reheats slower.
If you’re on the fence and the family is still growing, the 50 is usually the safer pick. Just measure first. A 50 gallon tank is taller or wider than a 40, and some closets and tight basement corners don’t have the room.

Gas Reheats Faster Than Electric
A gas burner heats water back up a lot faster than electric heating rods do, often about twice as fast. That means a 40 gallon gas tank can keep up with more people than a 40 gallon electric one. If your house is all electric, plan on going up one size from what a gas home would need. Deciding between gas and electric is its own question, and our installation page covers it.
Why Bigger Isn’t Always Better
It’s easy to think “just get the biggest one.” But a tank keeps every gallon hot all day and all night, whether anyone’s home or not. Heat slowly leaks out through the sides of the tank, and you pay to heat it back up. The bigger the tank, the more water you’re keeping hot for no reason.
A tank that’s too big also costs more up front and takes up more room. It happens a lot with couples whose kids moved out years ago. They’re still heating a 75 gallon tank for two people. When that one wears out, a smaller tank usually does the job just fine.

What About a Big Soaking Tub?
Here’s where a lot of people get surprised. Some soaking tubs and jetted tubs hold more water than a 40 gallon tank can give you hot in one go. You fill it halfway and the water coming out turns lukewarm. If you’ve got a big tub, or you’re putting one in, tell us how many gallons it holds. That number can push you up to a bigger tank.
When Tankless Makes More Sense
If your family is big enough that even a 50 or 75 gallon tank runs out, a tankless water heater may be the better fit. It heats water as you use it, so it doesn’t run out the same way. Our tankless water heater page explains what it takes to put one in.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a 40 gallon tank keep up with a family of five?
Usually not, at least not in the morning when three or four people want a shower in the same hour, and it gets even tighter with an electric tank. Most families of five do better with a 50 gallon tank, or a gas tank with a higher first hour rating on the yellow label, so the last person in line still gets a warm shower.
What size water heater does a house with just two people need?
For most couples, a 40 gallon tank is plenty, and a 30 gallon one can work if you never shower at the same time and don’t have a big tub. If one of you likes long, hot showers or you run the dishwasher and laundry in the morning too, stick with 40 so you have a little room to spare.
Can a family of seven get by on a 50 gallon water heater?
It can work if showers are spread out over the day, but with seven people a 50 gallon tank usually comes up short during the morning rush. Most big families do better with a larger tank, a tankless unit, or two tanks working together, so it’s worth having someone add up your busiest hour before you decide.
How many people can shower in a row on a 30 gallon tank?
Usually one long shower or two short ones before the water starts cooling off, and the second person might want to keep it quick. A 30 gallon tank works best for one person or a couple who shower at different times of the day, and anything more than that is usually a good reason to go up to 40.
Get the Right Size Water Heater in Oakville
When we size a new tank, we ask how many people live there, how many showers run in the morning, whether you’ve got a big tub, and if the house is gas or electric. Then we check the first hour rating on the actual tank, not just the gallons. That way you don’t end up with a cold shower or a tank that’s way bigger than you need.
Not sure what size water heater your family needs? Call Sam at (314) 600-2202, or send us a note through our contact page. We cover Oakville and all of St. Louis, and we pick up every day.
